The Cup Coffeehouse Menu

The Cup Coffeehouse in Wantagh, NY, offers a delightful menu that perfectly balances classic comfort with inventive twists. Their signature Apple Pie and Cherry Pie a La Mode stand out, delivering a warm, nostalgic bite paired exquisitely with rich coffee selections like the custom blend espresso or a creamy café latte. Dessert lovers will find joy in the Rainbow Cookie Cake, Chocolate Lava Cake, and the indulgent Coffee and S’mores Brownie Sundae—each crafted to satisfy both the eye and palate. Savory options such as Buffalo Chicken and Spicy Cajun Fries add a spicy kick, while lighter fare like the Eggplant Salad and Nutella Panini provide thoughtful variety. The unique tea lattes—London Fog, Blueberry Muffin, and Lavender Fog—offer aromatic, soothing alternatives to coffee. The cozy ambiance and friendly service enhance the experience, making each visit feel special. The Cup’s creative menu invites you to savor familiar flavors with a fresh, heartfelt approach, perfect for any time of day or night.